Crime and Privacy: Using Consumer Genomics to Identify Anonymous Individuals

So many people have had their DNA sequenced that they've put other people's privacy in jeopardy

About 60 percent of the USA population with European heritage may be identifiable from their DNA by searching consumer websites, even if they've never made their own genetic information available, a study estimates.

Yaniv Erlich, Tal Shor, Itsik Pe'er, and Shai Carmi, who are affiliated with online genealogy platform MyHeritage, as well as Columbia University, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and the New York Genome Center, last Thursday published a report in Science Magazine (Identity inference of genomic data using long-range familial searches) suggesting that as DNA databases continue to grow, investigators will be able to identify anyone in the USA given a sample of their DNA.

More than 15 million people have used direct-to-consumer genetic tests as of April, according to Erlich and his co-authors.

To prove this point, the researchers started with DNA information and a couple of basic details about an individual and, after finding a couple of their relatives via genetic archiving services they were able to determine who the person was without so much as a phone call.

Daniel MacArthur, a genomics researcher at Massachusetts General Hospital, said he endorses the cryptographic signature, but that it doesn't go far enough. In Erlich's words, "you fish in more ponds, you might find something".

As the case of the accused Golden State Killer brilliantly highlights, long-range familial searches are an incredible tool for law enforcement. A man believed to be the Golden State Killer, who was responsible for at least 12 murders and more than 50 rapes between 1976 and 1986, was arrested after investigators used publicly available ancestry databases to track him down.

Erlich, the author of the study, says he plans to get ahead of a potential crisis, to make sure that genetic genealogy does not become the focus of a leak scandal on par with the data breaches suffered by large companies such as Facebook.

People of purely African and Asian descent are less vulnerable because fewer people in those groups have had their DNA sequenced and put into a public database. So the team checked to see how many relatives on the order of a third cousin or closer they could find for each individual in their data set. The team found that a DNA sample from an American of Northern European heritage could be tracked successfully to a third-cousin distance of its owner in 60 percent of cases. He said that website does not allow forensic searches. CNN has reached out to GEDmatch for comment. "The problem is that the very same strategy can be misused". In 2013, his lab at the Whitehead Institute showed that it was possible to discover the identities of people who participate in genetic research studies by cross-referencing their data with other publicly available information.

"I used to be a vulnerability researcher, so I'm always thinking about how vulnerabilities can be exploited", Dr Erlich said.

Donald Trump praises Confederate icon Robert E. Lee at OH rally
During the rally, Trump said that despite Grant's drinking problem, Lincoln still turned to the Union general to defeat Lee. The news got a lot of attention, and the president took a lot of heat on social media for praising a confederate general .

4 dead, 1 injured in shooting at toddler’s birthday party
Juan Espinoza Jr, 43, was airlifted to a hospital in Corpus Christi, where he is in a critical condition. The man's 37-year-old father was also a suspect, but he had not yet been arrested, Sgt Brandley said.

Initial public offering: Anaplan stock surges 35% in trading debut
The company is going public with a new CFO, Dave Morton, who resigned from Tesla on September 4 after only a month at the troubled automaker.

"We found that once a genetic database covers roughly 2 percent of the adult population, a match of a third cousin or closer is expected for nearly all persons of interest", Carmi said in a statement.

So far, 72-year-old Joseph James DeAngelo is the most famous person to be identified this way.

A similar cross-referencing technique was recently used to break the long-cold case of the Golden State Killer after a relative's DNA popped up on a genetic testing site.

Research participants, the latest study found, could be identified with this newer technique, too.

Law enforcement agencies use all possible ways to find the criminals. "If the DNA sample is not available to do that, then what might typically be available would be the forensic genetic markers". Extensive genealogical data traced the identity of the perpetrator, which was confirmed by a standard DNA test.

"Therefore, even if a specific individual is not in these databases, a relative of theirs could be, which is enough to identify them".

With DNA databases "you need just a minute fraction of the population to really identify many more people", said Yaniv Erlich of Columbia University, an author of the study.

The closer you are with a relative, the more similar your genetic make-up is. First, they call for changes to rules that allow discarded material in clinics to be subject to genetic testing.

Related News:

  • Malaysia’s Anwar a Step Closer to Power

    Malaysia’s Anwar a Step Closer to Power

    Malaysian ex-deputy Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim has won a parliamentary seat, sealing his return to front-line politics. This is the third time he is returning to Parliament in a tumultuous political career that saw him jailed twice.
    Marvel's Iron Fist Has Been Cancelled By Netflix

    Marvel's Iron Fist Has Been Cancelled By Netflix

    Iron Fist stars Finn Jones , Jessica Henwick , Sacha Dhawan, Tom Pelphrey , Jessica Stroup, Simone Missick and Alice Eve. There are many fans of the character and the series and most people said that the second season was excellent.
    Trump against cancelling $110 billion arms deal with Saudi Arabia

    Trump against cancelling $110 billion arms deal with Saudi Arabia

    President Donald Trump is expected to call King Salman soon as questions mount about the disappearance of the Saudi journalist. The President said that Cengiz wrote "a handsome letter" to him and first lady Melania Trump and that they would welcome her.
  • MJ Akbar resigns amid #MeToo controversy

    MJ Akbar resigns amid #MeToo controversy

    According to the report, it was her last day of internship at the The Asian Age in 2007 when Akbar forced himself on her. Both Ms Ramani and Ms Wahab were in their early twenties when they first interacted with Mr Akbar.
    Butler practices again with Wolves, as opener nears

    Butler practices again with Wolves, as opener nears

    Butler had been absent for most of training camp and the preseason after he requested a trade from the team in September. Go up against the best, 'cause that's what I love to do. "Well, the thing is, it's always a challenge", the coach said.
    Ministry launches breast cancer awareness programme

    Ministry launches breast cancer awareness programme

    Regarding preventive health, we recommend women receive a mammography annually, starting when they are 45. The largest borough event honoring breast cancer survivors and raising money to find a cure is coming up.
  • Ariana Grande, Pete Davidson end engagement

    Ariana Grande, Pete Davidson end engagement

    After Miller's passing Grande chose not to make any public appearances or attend the Emmy awards with Davidson, according to ET . Grande's team told People that the singer needed time to "heal and mend" following the death of her ex-boyfriend Mac Miller .
    Robert E. Lee Descendent Attacks President Trump's Comments on Confederate General

    Robert E. Lee Descendent Attacks President Trump's Comments on Confederate General

    But on Sunday, NBC had to correct that tweet since, as it turns out, Trump was actually praising Union General (and future U.S. To further undermine the narrative of a dog whistle to his audience, the crowd did not applaud at the sound of Robert E.
    PlayStation 4 consoles are crashing because of a malicious message

    PlayStation 4 consoles are crashing because of a malicious message

    One suggestion is to download the PS Messages app onto your smart device of choice and delete the offending message from there. Another suggestion involves running a factory reset on your console, though you may want to look at that as a last resort.
  • Germany coach Joachim Low admits pressure is growing after Netherlands defeat

    Germany coach Joachim Low admits pressure is growing after Netherlands defeat

    Ryan Babel's header from a corner crashed against the crossbar and Van Dijk converted the rebound. They face world champions and group leaders France in the competition in Paris on Tuesday.
    Hillary Says Clinton Was ‘Absolutely’ Right to Not Resign Over Lewinsky Scandal

    Hillary Says Clinton Was ‘Absolutely’ Right to Not Resign Over Lewinsky Scandal

    Hillary Clinton says her husband was right to not step down amid the Monica Lewinsky scandal in the 1990s. Instead, Clinton brought up President Donald Trump's past, asking for an investigation.
    UK's Brexit chief rushes to Brussels for Sunday talks

    UK's Brexit chief rushes to Brussels for Sunday talks

    Mr Barnier said "some key issues are still open", including the so-called backstop measure to prevent a hard border. Instead, he suggested "conditions" could be set for the point at which "arrangements come to an end".


Most liked

The pope disrobes two bishops of chile
On Saturday Juan Carlos Cruz, one of Karadima's victims, tweeted that it was "a good day for the survivors of these monsters". The notice also referred to a canonical measure relating to "manifest abuse of minors" as being the reason for dismissal.

Netherlands vs. Germany - Football Match Report
The Netherlands will host Germany in a UEFA Nations League group matchup on Saturday, Oct. 13. Saturday's loss in Amsterdam was the first time Germany have lost by three goals to the Dutch.

Man loses leg after chainsaw attack on son backfires
Charges have been filed against the elder Ferguson and he is facing allegations of attempted second-degree murder and violation of parole.

Trump says climate change not a hoax, not sure of its source
She clarified she wanted to know if he made any mistakes, and all he would say is that he wished he'd done NAFTA sooner. Give me a break. "And then on top of that, they take advantage of us on trade". " Call Russia.

Official photos of Royal Wedding of Princess Eugenie and Jack Brooksbank released
Princess Eugenie of York and Jack Brooksbank embrace in the Scottish State Coach. The couple are said to be "delighted" to share the images.

Tom Brady leads Patriots by Chiefs in epic quarterback duel
Harmon had a huge play in the red-zone when he intercepted a Patrick Mahomes pass in the end zone at the end of the first half. It actually was a game in which, early on, the Patriots seemed to have some answers on defense for Mahomes and the Chiefs.

Sears files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection
Formed in 1886 by railroad station agent Richard Sears, the company started as a watch business in North Redwood, Minnesota. Having so little cash available would make it very hard for Sears to pay back $134 million in debt due on Monday.

Manchester United want Massimiliano Allegri to replace Jose Mourinho
For the majority of the campaign to date Jose Mourinho's men have lacked both a creative flair and ruthlessness in front of goal. United offered Allegri a three-year contract worth €9million to replace under-fire Jose Mourinho at Old Trafford.

Harry and Meghan arrive in Sydney for first royal tour
Prince Harry will launch the fourth Invictus Games in Sydney on Friday, and attend the opening and closing ceremonies. They were accompanied by a full entourage of staff and security as they walked into view of the waiting media pool.

Future of Patisserie Valerie hangs in the balance
Before the suspension, Patisserie Holdings had a market value of 446 million pounds ($590 million). The company's updated statement said it was taking two pieces of action to shore up its finances.

UK, France, Germany demand response on Jamal Khashoggi's disappearance
Trump visited the kingdom on his first overseas trip as president and has touted arms sales to Saudi Arabia. By close , it had recovered some losses, ending down 3.5 percent and losing $16.5 billion of market value.

Seann Walsh girlfriend Rebecca Humphries praised by Women's Aid
In an interview with Heat magazine, published just as his wife's kiss emerged, the 35-year-old insisted: 'I have more of a bromance with her partners'.

United Kingdom and U.S. 'could boycott' Saudi conference over missing reporter
When asked if he would impose sanctions on the Saudis, he said it "depends on what the sanction is". Those policies are all seen as initiatives of the crown prince.

May's team must force change in Brexit policy, says former minister
The Prime Minister will have a cabinet meeting on Tuesday before she heads to Brussels and she may struggle to get a consensus. An EU official said no further negotiations were planned before the leaders of EU countries convene in Brussels.

Woman's apology after CCTV exposes her sick claim against boy
However, her neighbors disputed that assertion, claiming that she has written "racial slurs" in chalk outside the building. Facebook video taken in the immediate aftermath of the incident shows the woman calling the police outside the store.