Bakery wins 'gay cake' court appeal

Bakery wins 'gay cake' court appeal

In a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court ruled the Christian owners of Ashers Baking co were not obliged by law to make a cake featuring the words "Support Gay Marriage".

Ashers bakery's general manager Daniel McArthur took the order to "spare Mr Lee any embarrassment", but the couple then decided they "could not in conscience produce a cake with that slogan", cancelled the order and offered Lee a refund.

Lee ordered the cake in Belfast for a private function marking International Day Against Homophobia.

It failed in an appeal to the local courts in 2016 but the Supreme Court, the UK's highest judicial body, overturned that decision on Wednesday, saying the bakers' objection was to the message on the cake, not to any personal characteristics of the messenger, or anyone with whom he was associated.

"But that is not what happened in this case". They also decided that no-one was refused services or work based upon their religious beliefs, and therefore ruled in favour of Ashers.

But the ruling was hailed by the socially conservative Democratic Unionist Party (DUP), the province's largest party that props up Britain's minority government and has blocked attempts to legalise gay marriage in the province.

After fours years of duking it out in the courts, the U.K. Supreme Court has now ruled on the side of Ashers Bakery.

The Northern Ireland Equality Commission spent £150,000 (€190,000, $205,000) of public money in backing Lee in the case, while Ashers spent £200,000, covered by The Christian Institute, a charity and lobby group.

Fabinho speaks out after quiet start to Liverpool career
But under their new manager Unai Emery, the Gunners have made sure they keep a close eye on the league leaders and now just 2 points behind them.

Cleveland Browns: 3 players whose stock dropped against the Ravens
Mayfield gives the Browns a chance to attack the Ravens in the middle of the field. This kick in overtime was good, though.

Scientist: Tuesday, October 8, meteor shower Draconid will be the most active
According to EarthSky.org, the Draconid meteors burst out into the skies near the Draco stars of Eltanin and Rastaban. The Draconids are best seen in the evening hours when the skies are darkening enough to pick out individual meteors.

Daniel and Amy McArthur, and Daniel's parents Karen and Colin McArthur, run Ashers Bakery in Northern Ireland.

"They have strongly underlined the law on compelled speech, quoting a previous case which said "Nobody should be forced to have or express a political opinion in which he does not believe", he said.

The president of the Supreme Court, Lady Hale, agreed with that argument and found the bakery did not refuse to fulfil the order because of Mr Lee's sexual orientation.

Lady Hale added: "The bakers could not refuse to supply their goods to Mr Lee because he was a gay man or supported gay marriage, but that is quite different from obliging them to supply a cake iced with a message with which they profoundly disagreed. I'm concerned that this has implications for myself and for every single person".

"The effort to impose the LGBT agenda on Christian businesses by compelling promotion of their political demands, irrespective of the conscience or religious belief of the business owner, needed to be reined in".

The legal fees for the Northern Ireland case are estimated to be more than $800,000 combined.

The McArthurs appealed, but after losing their appeal, they took their case to the United Kingdom's Supreme Court.

He said: "We're delighted and relieved at today's ruling". Human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell and John O'Doherty, director of the Northern Ireland LGBT organisation, Rainbow Project, debate.

Related News:

  • Vikas Bahl issues legal notice to Anurag Kashyap and Vikramaditya Motwane

    Vikas Bahl issues legal notice to Anurag Kashyap and Vikramaditya Motwane

    However, the piece was also critical of Mr Kashyap's way of handling the matter, including the delay in calling Vikas Bahl out. Unfortunately, the film industry knew of their actions but chose to remain silent and with it every victim was silenced.
    McConnell says challenging Trump in 2020 'a waste of time'

    McConnell says challenging Trump in 2020 'a waste of time'

    Add Supreme Court as an interest to stay up to date on the latest Supreme Court news, video, and analysis from ABC News. And on Monday evening he was the guest of honour at a ceremonial swearing-in at the White House.
    Trump Administration Examines Path to Waive Iranian Oil Sanctions

    Trump Administration Examines Path to Waive Iranian Oil Sanctions

    Iran was exporting between 2.5 and 2.7 million bpd in April before the USA announced the return of sanctions. India is the world's third-largest oil importer, and Iran's second-biggest oil customer after China.
  • Space telescope Hubble has failed

    Space telescope Hubble has failed

    Assuming the team can rescue the malfunctioning gyroscope, Hubble will resume operations in its standard three-gyro configuration. Rachel Osten of the Hubble team confirmed that something is wrong with the telescope's gyroscopes, which it uses for orientation.
    Roger Federer warns Nick Kyrgios over work ethic after Shanghai Masters fiasco

    Roger Federer warns Nick Kyrgios over work ethic after Shanghai Masters fiasco

    It didn't end there as Kyrgios turned to Dumusois after hitting an ace and sarcastically asked: " Was that borderline poor? ". The talented but erratic Kyrgios has played in Shanghai four times with his best showing being two second-round finishes.
    Sydney at odds over horseracing adverts on opera house roof

    Sydney at odds over horseracing adverts on opera house roof

    NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian has backed Alan Jones' position in favour of horse race advertising on the Sydney Opera House. Why not put it on the biggest billboard Sydney has", Morrison, a former head of Tourism Australia, told reporters.
  • The IMF again downgrades outlook for the global economy

    The IMF again downgrades outlook for the global economy

    If pressures on emerging market economies were to broaden and intensify, financial stability risks would increase significantly, he said.

    Samantha Markle claims she wasn't turned away from Kensington Palace

    Samantha, along with Meghan's father Thomas Markle , did not attend Meghan's nuptials in May. Samantha explained: "I was very respectful and I went there to deliver a letter".
    Five killed in torrential rainstorms in Majorca

    Five killed in torrential rainstorms in Majorca

    Other victims were found in Arta and the coastal town of S'illot, where the overflowed creek reaches the sea. Antonia Bauza, the deputy mayor of Sant Llorenc, confirmed two of the victims were British nationals.
  • Brooks Koepka named PGA of America's Player of the Year

    Brooks Koepka named PGA of America's Player of the Year

    Coming off a wrist injury that sidelined him for four months, Koepka finished ninth in the FedEx Cup standings, a career best. Brothers may argue, brothers get into it".
    Climate report understates threat

    Climate report understates threat

    The impacts of 1.5°C of warming and the possible development pathways by which the world could get there are its main focus. For instance, the Arctic is already experiencing warming that is many times higher than the global average.
    Pet Sematary Trailer: What’s Dead Should Stay Dead

    Pet Sematary Trailer: What’s Dead Should Stay Dead

    Check out the trailer below and get ready because very soon we'll have a full report from the set of the Stephen King adaptation. Jason Clarke and Amy Seimetz play Louis and Rachel Creed, the mom and dad of a young family that's new to this country road.


Most liked

Rare 'polio-like' disease reported in Minnesota and Colorado
All the children showed systems of a respiratory illness the week before developing symptoms of AFM. This follows an unusual rise this year in cases of acute flaccid myelitis (AFM) in several states.

Authorities: 'Real Housewives' husband Joe Giudice to be deported
The couple shares four children together - 17-year-old Gia, 14-year-old Gabriella, 13-year-old Milania and 9-year-old Audriana. Joe Giudice will be deported back to Italy once he's released from prison next year, according to a judge's ruling today.

Wall Street tumbles as investors take the knife to tech companies
The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 3.15 percent, the S&P 500 lost 3.29 percent, and the Nasdaq Composite dropped 4.08 percent. It followed a bleak session in Europe, where Germany's Dax and France's Cac 40 had each ended the day more than 2% lower.

50 people dead in bus crash in western Kenya
Kericho County Police Commander James Mogera said the casualties could rise since more people were still trapped in the wreckage. Kenya has struggled to reduce the rising number of road accidents as more people in the growing middle class acquire vehicles.

Ice shards 15 metres high 'cover' Jupiter's moon
Any robotic spacecraft landing on the moon will have to navigate its way around lethal obstacles, a new study suggests. This process leaves behind distinctive, blade-like formations called penitentes .

Lana Del Rey Confronts Azealia Banks
She criticizing Del Rey's appearance , saying she had bad plastic surgery and making other body-shaming comments. On Oct. 9, Del Rey clapped back at Banks with this tweet: "Pull up anytime". "I won't not f**k you the f**k up".

Heat interested in restarting Butler trade talks
As the GM watched on the sidelines during a scrimmage, sources said that Butler yelled to Layden: "You f--ing need me, Scott". Butler had previously been excused from training camp and preseason games as the team dealt with his trade request.

Sears hires advisers for bankruptcy filing
While much of his focus revolved around Sears's online presence, upkeep on physical stores has diminished. Where we were: Sears's struggles are nothing new, and have been an overhang for some real estate owners.

Prince William Makes a Corny Dad Joke at Kate Middleton's Expense
Last month Prince William opened up about the emotional toll of witnessing suffering during his time as an air ambulance pilot. Kate Middleton and Prince William stepped out in London on Tuesday to attend the Global Ministerial Mental Health Summit .

Google announces its first tablet in three years, the Pixel Slate
The Pixel 3 and its big brother also have a dedicated security chip - the Titan M, which keeps the OS and your passwords secure. The Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL obviously both ship with the latest and greatest version of Android, which is Android 9.0 Pie.

American Music Awards - All The Performances: Watch Here!
"I'd never come up with a title before", Taylor said while accepting Favorite Album - Pop/Rock for reputation . Mariah Carey sang her new song "With You" dressed in a form-fitting pink gown and surrounded by male dancers.

Vitamin D supplements are declared useless
Supplements are advised in particular for those with bone conditions such as osteoporosis , which typically affects older people. Vitamin D supplementation was shown to have no effect on total fracture, hip fracture or falls.

How to be a better friend to someone with mental health issues
According to the global agency, 10 to 20 per cent of children and adolescents worldwide suffer from mental disorders. For more information or professional help, visit their website .

Dubai Test: Finch, Khawaja dominate Pakistan with half centuries
That was enough for Langer to confirm one-day specialist Finch and South Australia skipper Head would play their first tests . Hafeez registered a century as he and his opening partner Imam-ul Haq (76) shared a 201-run partnership for the first wicket.

DUP 'could vote against the Budget' over Brexit deal
Earlier in the day, she told BBC Radio Ulster that it is "eminently possible" to reach a Brexit deal that "works for everyone" with weeks.