Challenge to Section 377: SC frowns on Centre’s delay in filing response

Governance       Constitutionality of 377 first personal rights later CJI says on rights of homosexuals
       
       	        Ritika Jain         10 July 2018

The court ruled privacy was a fundamental right of all Indians, adding that sexual orientation was an essential attribute of privacy.

The only question, therefore, which is referred for the consideration of larger bench is the question of constitutional validity of criminalizing "consensual acts of adults in private" falling under Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code and no other questions fall for consideration of this Hon'ble Bench as evident from the order of reference.

The bench, led by Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra, however, refused and listed it for today. Let us get out of this maze. They should get jobs on merit, but we can not allow them to celebrate.

"We want them to have a normal economic life. I am not appearing now as the Attorney General", he told.

After the apex court had set aside the Delhi High Court's 2009 judgement decriminalising sex between consenting adults of same sex by holding as "illegal" Section 377 of IPC, review petitions were filed, and on their dismissal curative petitions were filed by the affected parties for re-examination of the original verdict.

Iran says Trump 'destabilising' oil market
South Korean embassy in Tehran on Saturday denied that the country has stopped oil imports from Iran, IRAN Daily reported. Even if the Europeans cave in to U.S. demands, the world has changed a great deal since the pre-Iran deal era.

JetBlue Flight Attendants Saved French Bulldog Who Couldn't Breathe on Flight
JetBlue released a statement to ABC News about the incident, which could have been unsafe had flight crew not reacted. Darcy, a three-year-old French bulldog, started panting heavily on her flight from Orlando to MA last week.

Yaşar Güler appointed as Turkey's new Chief of Staff
In a speech on Saturday, Erdogan said he would tackle high-interest rates, inflation and a wide current account deficit. Erdogan appointed his son-in-law as Turkey's finance minister on Monday hours after taking his oath of office.

The bench, which also included Justices R.F. Nariman, A.M. Khanwilkar and Indu Malhotra, on Tuesday commenced hearing a batch of petitions and cross-petitions for and against the section. It denies LGBT persons, their right to full personhood, sexuality, sexual autonomy, and choice of sexual partner, which are implicit in the notion of life under Article 21 of the Constitution. "The question here is whether Section 377 is ultra vires (beyond one's legal power) or not". Suppose your partner tries to sue you for some kind of right. or, say, file a case under the domestic violence act. such issues will be debated when a lis (issue) comes to court.

The apex court in its privacy judgment held that "discrimination against an individual on the basis of sexual orientation is deeply offensive to the dignity and self-worth of the individual. We can not have an advanced ruling". Even the Centre had at that time favoured retention of the provision in the IPC as penal offence.

Anwesh Pokkuluri, along with 19 others who are present and former students of IITs across the country, had moved the Supreme Court in May which sought to challenge the constitutional validity of section 377. The CJI said, "Live-streaming and recording of court proceedings will help the public know instantly about the important developments in the court". This, petitioners claim is a direct violation of Articles 14, 15, 16, 19 and 21 of the Constitution which guaranty Indian citizens various fundamental rights like freedom of expression, equal protection of the law, equality of opportunity and personal liberty. "Moreover, homosexuality is not a disease".

The arguments would resume on Wednesday.

Related News:



Most liked

Duke and Duchess of Sussex arrive in Ireland on first worldwide trip
And in a cosy selfie with the designer a year ago , she wrote: 'Because lunch with @roland_mouret is the very best kind of lunch'. Harry and Meghan's engagements will include official meetings with Taoiseach Leo Varadkar and President Michael D Higgins.

Neville thought 3 England stars would struggle at World Cup
Some Tottenham Hotspur fans have ripped into Chelsea striker Olivier Giroud after his France performance at the World Cup. We know what it takes and in such moments you forget any fatigue you may feel", said the 29-year-old Liverpool player.

Pivac named as Wales rugby coach from 2019
Gatland is a two-time British and Irish Lions head coach, winning one series in Australia and tying with the All Blacks a year ago .

Trump stokes tensions with United States allies ahead of North Atlantic Treaty Organisation summit
His comments come only hours before he's due to meet German chancellor Angela Merkel on the side lines of the summit in Brussels . Trump was referring to the controversial $12 billion proposed Nord Stream 2 pipeline between Russian Federation and Germany.

Liverpool open talks with Stoke City over Xherdan Shaqiri transfer
Fekir, in any case, is still with France at the World Cup and would not be due to return to action until early-August. Shaqiri joined Stoke in 2015 from Inter Milan before going on to make 84 league appearances for the club.

Fitness app revealed data on military, intelligence personnel
Polar monitors heart rate, location , route, date and time of the training, the information can be shared on the social platform. Polar ultimately made a decision to disable the map on its website, preventing others from recreating this research.

Michael Ondaatje's English Patient wins Booker Prize's 50th anniversary award
Novelist Kamila Shamsie , the jurist who selected the English Patient as a Golden Booker finalist, called the novel "transformative".

Watchdog urges record £500000 fine for Facebook over Cambridge Analytica data scandal
The decision was welcomed by former Cambridge Analytica employee and whistleblower Christopher Wylie. Politicians are calling for greater transparency from Facebook in light of the ICO fine.

William and Kate’s third child, Prince Louis, christened
Harry Aubrey-Fletcher: He went to Ludgrove School and Eton with William and his father is the Lord Lieutenant of Buckinghamshire. Prince William , Prince Charles and the queen, for example, were all christened in the Music Room of Buckingham Palace.

Rangers announce ninth summer signing
Coulibaly is excited to play under Gerrard but admitted he was not sure if it was a joke or not. Sadiq joins Rangers after having spent last season on loan at Torino and Dutch side NAC Breda.

Elon Musk proposes mini-submarine to save Thai cave boys
The group was found nine days later in a cramped chamber 2.5 miles inside the cave system by two British volunteer rescue divers . All four boys brought out of the cave on Monday were taken by ambulance to a waiting helicopter which ferried them to hospital.

Meghan Markle Stuns In Black Dior To Mark RAF's 100th Anniversary Celebrations
Harry and Meghan later joined royals at a Buckingham Palace reception to mark the centenary of the Royal Air Force . So it is no wonder that both Prince William and Prince Harry appeared honored to be present for the celebrations.

Cristiano Ronaldo Juventus transfer reportedly close, sending shares rocketing
Ronaldo led Portugal to a Euro win in 2016, but flamed out of the 2018 World Cup in the Round of 16 with a loss to Uruguay. I am leaving but I will always feel that this jersey, this badge and the Santiago Bernabéu are mine, no matter where I am.

UAE supermarkets recall frozen food following killer listeria outbreak in Europe
Listeria is a life-threatening illness for certain people, particularly those over the age of 60. In healthy people, the infection may be mistaken for a mild viral infection or flu.

South Africa's Van Rooyen leads Irish Open by 4
If I had 100 putts every week I played and hit the ball halfway decent, I'd win every week". "I'm really disappointed. Wish I could birdie the two par fives but I didn't. "I just wish I could have birdied the two par fives".