Facebook job ads allow age discrimination, lawsuit claims

Facebook defends ad targeting meant to discriminate against older workers

For a vast majority of the hundreds of millions of people who check Facebook every day, the ad did not exist.

Major U.S. employers engaged in age discrimination by placing recruitment ads on Facebook targeting specific age groups, according to a lawsuit filed by a communications industry labor union on Wednesday.

In the end, is Facebook to blame or the advertisers?

"These companies eliminate older workers from receiving job ads by specifically targeting their employment ads to younger workers via Facebook's ad platform", the suit alleges, displaying two images reportedly from Facebook.

Is this OK? According to the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967, it probably isn't, because showing age bias when hiring is not lawful, according to the act. Many jurisdictions make it unlawful to "aid" or "abet" age discrimination, a provision that could apply to companies like Facebook that distribute job ads.

Facebook defended the practice.

"Used responsibly, age-based targeting for employment purposes is an accepted industry practice and for good reason", Rob Goldman, Facebook's VP of ads, responded in a blog post.

But, this time round, the company claims it's doing no wrong.

Haley warns against Jerusalem resolution ahead of United Nations vote
East Jerusalem, which Palestinians are seeking to make the capital of their state, has been under Israeli occupation since 1967. I think we should wait for the voting to happen.

Texas sees first girl play, score in high school football championship game
A high school kicker in Texas made history this week when she became the first female football player to score in a Texas high school state championship game.

North Korea to the US: We aren't responsible for WannaCry
Neither the White House nor North Korea's Ministry of Foreign Affairs immediately responded to CNET's request for comment. In addition, the NIS said there were attempts to breach about 10 more cryptocurrency exchanges last month alone.

Facebook has argued in court filings that the law, the Communications Decency Act, makes it immune from liability for discriminatory ads. A new investigation released today revealed that the company also allows advertisers potentially to discriminate by age. LinkedIn changed its system to exclude age, Google did not.

"We completely reject the allegation that these advertisements are discriminatory", said Goldman of Facebook told ProPublica.

Background: The legal challenge is seeking class action status in order to represent Facebook users 40 or older who may have been denied the opportunity to know about certain open job openings.

In searching through its own recruitment ads, Facebook found examples of ad creative differing by context.

An exhibit (PDF) shows screenshots of other age-targeted ads. And State Farm ads collected by ProPublica were mainly targeted at people between 19 and 35. Tech companies like to describe themselves as passive vessels for others' publishing decisions, to stay within reach of "safe harbour" defences.

Facebook itself was also a part of the companies that ran the age-based career ads.

In its response, Facebook defended its own age-targeted recruitment advertisements as part of "broader-based recruitment efforts created to reach all ages and all backgrounds". "The screenshot to the right shows that T-Mobile sent the job ad because T-Mobile 'wants to reach people ages 18 to 38 who live or were recently in the United States'". The ad is accompanied by an explanation titled "Why am I seeing this ad".

Facebook's targeted ad tools have landed it in hot water again. In Amazon's case, for jobs at its distribution centers, it changed 18-50 to anyone over the age of 18. "For some of our social-media ads, we look to get the content to the people most likely to be interested but do not exclude anyone from our recruiting activity".

Related News:



Most liked

North Korea tensions ratchet up over WannaCry attack
Manfra praised Microsoft and Facebook for their efforts to combat WannaCry and to block more recent attempts to hack US systems. A South Korean lawmaker in October said North Korean hackers stole highly classified military documents that include U.S.

Trump officials implore Congress to renew intelligence law
Ryan suggested Tuesday, lawmakers would be tasked with balancing three different proposed revisions. This would not apply to counterterrorism or counterintelligence cases, however.

Local vet allegedly shoots and kills barking dog
A Louisana veterinarian is accused of fatally shooting a neighbor's bulldog in its head because she was fed up with its barking . Folse's family called the allegations against her outrageous and told WWL that Folse is and has always been an animal lover.

United Nations envoy says time is ripe to promote Syria political process
Swedish Ambassador Olof Skoog, who co-sponsored the resolution with Egypt and Japan, argued the mandate will help save lives. The cross-border program "remains a vital humanitarian lifeline for 3 million people in Syria", he said.

Coalition raids hit Yemen rebels after missile targets Riyadh
Lebanese Prime Minister Saad al-Hariri condemned the attack, saying such actions exacerbated divisions in the region. Saudi Arabia has not confirmed this account or whether a meeting of its leaders was taking place.

Rome under fire for 'mangy' Christmas tree
The Rome's official Christmas tree stands in front of the Unknown monument in Piazza Venezia Square. The city has no plans to move Spelacchio, council sources have told the press.

Ian Wright slams Arsenal board over Mesut Ozil and Alexis Sanchez contracts
That could change in January if other clubs move for the Chilean - but City remain relaxed and confident he wants to join them. But plans to sign a new left-back have been abandoned thanks to the excellent transition of Fabian Delph in recent months.

Not-So-Secret Santa: New Zealand PM's Gift Gives Away Identity
Apparently, New Zealanders have joined in a nationwide Secret Santa game along with their Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern . The Prime Minister was given a framed drawing of Auckland's Sky Tower by Zara of Panmure Bridge School.

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle release official engagement photographs
The photographs of Meghan Markle , 36, and Prince Harry , 33, were taken by Alex Lubomirski at Frogmore House, Windsor. The more intimate shot, with Prince Harry and his bride-to-be snuggling for the camera, looks not unlike a jewelry ad.

Bank Amer Corp (BAC) Holder F&V Capital Management LLC Has Cut Holding
Signature Estate & Limited Liability holds 1.94% of its portfolio in Bank of America Corporation (NYSE: BAC ) for 686,496 shares. The investor is now holding $96.55 million shares due in part to a decrease of 30.18 million new shares in their portfolio.

Forecast: Complicated Christmas Weekend Forecast
Wind chills will head back to the 20s by Christmas afternoon, but we get sunshine back for Christmas Eve and Christmas Day . Another storm will move into the region Sunday night with snow developing across the Midcoast by sunrise Christmas morning.

Auto 'deliberately' ploughs into Christmas shoppers in Melbourne leaving 19 injured
He had a history of drug use and mental health issues, and had been undergoing treatment for mental illness, Patton said. At 5pm local time (6am GMT), a white Suzuki SUV charged through a crowd of pedestrians in Melbourne's city centre.

Irish youngster to play Artemis Fowl in Disney movie
Ferdia Shaw has been tapped to play the title role in Disney's " Artemis Fowl ", which is being directed by Kenneth Branagh . And we're happy to report Disney has finally found their Artemis Fowl and cast newcomer Ferdia Shaw as the titular character.

China ride-hail firm Didi raises $4 billion for global push
Didi now accounts for 99 per cent of the car-hailing market in China, with 300 million customers in over 400 cities. Uber didn't immediately respond to an email request for comment sent outside regular business hours.

Keep chocolates away from dogs as Christmas season sets in
According to Hills Pet , baking chocolate, cocoa, and dark chocolate are the most unsafe theobromine-containing items for dogs. The team found that around Easter, dogs were twice as likely to have chocolate exposure than on non-holidays.